I remember standing in a roastery, holding a bag for longer than I should have. I had already started caring about coffee. That was part of the problem. I knew just enough to feel like I should know more.
But I don’t want anyone who worked there to know that. So I stayed quiet.
I read the bags instead. Slowly. Twice sometimes. Trying to work out what “jasmine” or “stone fruit” would actually taste like in my cup at home.
When someone did approach to ask if I needed help, I kept it short. Just enough to get through the moment.
I’d pick something, pay, and leave.
It took me longer than it should have to realise how much value there was in chatting to my roaster. Once I started talking, things got easier. I stopped guessing. I stopped trying to decode what’s written on the bag. And I started picking coffee I really enjoyed.
Here’s what I learnt are the 8 most important things to chat to your coffee roaster about.
What you’ve actually enjoyed drinking
Start with something you know. Not what looks good. Not what sounds interesting.
What you’ve had before that you’d happily drink again. If a coffee felt too sharp, say that. If it felt heavy in a way you didn’t enjoy, say that as well.
You don’t need to get it right.
“I usually go for something more chocolatey.”
That’s enough.
How you’re making coffee at home
Say this early. It shapes the recommendation more than anything else.
The same coffee will behave differently depending on how you brew it. A pourover can bring out one side of it. Espresso will show you something else.
So just say it. “I’m using a French press.” “I make espresso.” “I brew with a V60.”
Now the conversation has some direction.
When the coffee was roasted
Look for the date. If you don’t see it, ask.
I’ve taken coffee home that was too fresh to use properly. It ran fast and tasted uneven. I’ve also used coffee that had been sitting on the shelf longer than I realised. It brewed fine but didn’t have much to it.
Knowing when it was roasted doesn’t fix everything, but it tells you what you’re working with.
What it tastes like without the language
You read a bag and see a list of flavour notes. They look impressive. They don’t always help.
Ask for a plain description.
How it feels to drink. Whether it leans heavier or lighter. Whether it’s something you’ll recognise straight away or not.
What they’re drinking right now
Ask them what they’re enjoying at the moment. And how they’re preparing it.
It usually comes with a better explanation. How it’s being brewed. What stands out. Where it might not work.
That’s more useful than comparing bags on your own.
Whether something isn’t working at home
Sometimes you’re not just buying coffee. You’re trying to fix something.
If something isn’t working at home, say it.
“It keeps coming out sour.” “I can’t get it to taste right.”
Whether you need it ground
If you don’t have a good grinder, ask them to grind it for you. Tell them how you brew, and they’ll set it accordingly.
Grinding at home only helps if your grinder is consistent. If it isn’t, a proper grind in the shop will usually give you a better result.
There’s a trade off. Ground coffee loses aroma faster, so buy smaller amounts and use it within a few days. And/or have an excellent storage solution.
What to avoid
If you know you don’t enjoy bright coffees, say that. If you don’t like anything that feels too heavy, say that as well.
It’s easier to remove options than to pick from everything in front of you.
How to buy coffee at a roastery without overthinking it
Most people don’t need more information. They need a way to act on what they already know.
When you walk into a coffee roastery, you don’t need to understand every detail on the bag. You need to start a useful conversation.
Tell them what you like. Tell them how you brew.
That’s enough to get you most of the way there. The rest comes with time and repetition.
Frequently asked questions
What should I ask when buying coffee at a roastery
Tell them what you usually enjoy and how you brew your coffee. That gives them enough to recommend something that fits.
How do I choose coffee beans at a roastery
Focus on direction rather than detail. Decide if you prefer chocolatey or fruit forward coffees, then share that with the roaster.
Do I need to understand coffee tasting notes
No. Tasting notes are helpful, but a simple description of what you like works better in most cases.
Should I grind coffee at home or at the roastery
If you have a consistent grinder, grind at home. If not, getting it ground at the roastery will usually give you a better result.
Why does coffee from a roastery taste better
Roastery coffee is usually fresher and better suited to how you brew it, especially when you speak to the roaster and get guidance.
Discover more from FLTR Magazine
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
